What makes a Broadway musical a classic? Most people would suggest that a musical’s shelf life is a big part of what elevates it to the status of an enduring masterpiece. Does a musical have staying power? Others might suggest that a memorable score full of hits would do the trick. Still, others insist a strong story and relatable characters create the perfect storm. This spring, Broadway audiences find themselves looking forward to two revivals of classic musicals that continue to endure the test of time: Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Carousel and Lerner and Loewe’s My Fair Lady. Both proved to be game-changers in the history of American musical theater and helped the art form to evolve. What is it about these favorites that has allowed them to achieve the status of masterpiece? Let’s look at each of their histories for a better understanding.
In 1943, after an ecstatic response to their first collaboration, Oklahoma! (a musical that established a new structure and formula for musical-theater writing), the songwriting team of Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein set about looking for a property for their next project. They turned to Ferenc Molnar’s 1909 play Liliom, about a carousel barker and a young maid in Budapest, Hungary, who fall in love and then face a relationship of tragedy, heartbreak, and domestic violence. The play was not well received when it first opened in Budapest, but when it traveled to America in 1921 to play on Broadway, it was a major success.
Rodgers and Hammerstein understood that Liliom would need some alterations for it to be successful as a Broadway musical. One of the chief changes that was made was to move the locale from Budapest to a New England fishing village in the late 1800s (though they had contemplated setting it in rural Louisiana). The name of the male lead was changed from Liliom to Billy Bigelow, and the character of Julie (retaining her name) went from being a maid to a mill worker. The new musical that emerged was dubbed Carousel, and in it, Rodgers and Hammerstein perfected on the form and revolutions that they established with Oklahoma!
Opening at Broadway’s Majestic Theatre (the current home of The Phantom of the Opera) on April 19, 1945, Rouben Mamoulian helmed Carousel as director and Agnes de Mille created the legendary choreography. Both, of course, had done the same for Oklahoma!, but Carousel offered them an opportunity to dig deeper and create more confidently, seamlessly tying staging and dancing, elegantly letting them flow in and out of one another. Rodgers and Hammerstein also flourished with Carousel, taking the integrated score to new heights, perhaps never more breathtaking than in the “Bench Scene/If I Loved You” sequence, where dialogue, recitation, and full-on musical theater blended in an exquisite symphony of magic.
Carousel featured a score that was brimming with what would become some of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s most beloved standards. The aforementioned “If I Loved You,” sung with palpable angst and dreamy hope by Jan Clayton and John Raitt, was a highlight. Raitt made a tour de force out of the emotionally vacillating monologue “Soliloquy,” and Clayton broke our hearts with “What’s the Use of Wond’rin?” Skipping an overture to open the show, the curtain rose on the innovative action-in-progress, staged without a dance number, the infectious “Carousel Waltz.” One cannot speak of Carousel without mentioning its anthem of hope, “You’ll Never Walk Alone,” a song of perseverance and fortitude that became a standard well outside the confines of the show.
Carousel is often pointed to as the greatest of the Rodgers and Hammerstein musicals. It was certainly a favorite of Rodgers, who thought it was the best score of his career. In its initial run, Carousel ran 890 performances (the fifth longest of the decade), though it never found the endurance that Oklahoma! did (2,212 performances). It remains, however, one of the most revived musicals in the Rodgers and Hammerstein collection. Its subject matter is grittier and darker than most of the other Rodgers and Hammerstein musicals, and that may be why it seldom runs as long as their other hits. That reason, however, is arguably what attracts interest in revivals of Carousel. It is a complex piece of musical theater about imperfect human beings being human.
If Carousel seemed to be an easy transition from play to musical, My Fair Lady had a harder time coming to fruition along that path. George Bernard Shaw’s 1914 play Pygmalion is about a Cockney flower girl who is given lessons in being a high-society lady by a chauvinistic phonetics professor who believes he can change her social status by perfecting her articulation. A Hungarian film producer named Gabriel Pascal believed that Shaw’s play had all the makings of a musical, a Cinderella-type story with a message about social class structure. As Pascal shopped around for composers to take on the project, he soon found that many composers and lyricists were either not interested in “musicalizing” Pygmalion or they took a stab at it, only to decide that it couldn’t be done. Among those who passed: Rodgers and Hammerstein.
The team of Alan Jay Lerner and Frederick Loewe had found some modest success in writing for the Broadway stage. Up to then, their biggest hit had been the 1947 fantasy musical Brigadoon, which has itself proven to be an enduring classic. This was followed by the 1951 also-ran Paint Your Wagon, a musical with a superior score that lasted 289 performances. They were a respected duo of the musical stage, the heirs apparent of Rodgers and Hammerstein in style and form. When faced with the opportunity to turn Pygmalion into a musical, Lerner and Loewe were intrigued at the possibilities and set about to write what many thought would prove to be the end of the duo’s careers on Broadway.
By this point, the Rodgers and Hammerstein format for writing musicals — having the music and lyrics grow out of the plot and characters’ experiences — was the way musicals were typically written. Lerner, as both book writer and lyricist, was the sparkling match of wit and wordplay to Shaw’s style. Indeed, it is hard to know where Shaw leaves off and Lerner picks up in musical numbers such as “Why Can’t the English?,” “I’m an Ordinary Man,” “A Hymn to Him,” “Without You,” and “I’ve Grown Accustomed to her Face.” To add to the class and charm of the piece, Frederick Loewe brought a European grandeur to what was now titled My Fair Lady. The lush melodies of “I Could Have Danced All Night” and “On the Street Where You Live” are indicative of Loewe’s “Old World” style and contributed to the score’s popularity.
My Fair Lady opened at Broadway’s Mark Hellinger Theatre on March 15, 1956. Playwright and director Moss Hart directed the show, with Hanya Holm taking care of the choreography. Among the cast were the clarion-voiced Julie Andrews in the role of Eliza Doolittle. Rex Harrison was cast as Professor Henry Higgins, a role for which he would become forever synonymous, winning a Tony and eventually an Academy Award for the film version, playing this fussy, grumbling, petulant professor of phonetics. Rounding out the trio of leading players was English music hall comedian Stanley Holloway as Eliza’s father, who would introduce the showstopping “With a Little Bit of Luck” and “Get Me to the Church on Time.”
Carousel had opened in a time before Tony Awards were handed out (missing it by just a few years). My Fair Lady, on the other hand, opened after the Tony tradition had started and it took home the award for Best Musical. My Fair Lady ran for a record-breaking 2,717 performances and went on to become an Oscar-winning Best Picture in 1964 (with Audrey Hepburn playing Eliza Doolittle and Harrison and Holloway reprising their roles).
Clearly, both My Fair Lady and Carousel are classics of the American musical theater. No one factor can be held responsible for their successes. It is a combination of inspired writing, memorable music, and brilliant staging that has given both these musicals the distinction of becoming masterpieces. They are elastic enough in their themes and story lines to endure the test of time, to be reinterpreted through revival after revival. We look forward to seeing Carousel and My Fair Lady assume their latest incarnations this spring on Broadway.
Mark Robinson is the author of the two-volume encyclopedia The World of Musicals and maintains a theater and entertainment blog at markrobinsonwrites.com.
Last updated and effective as of January 14, 2019
Introduction and Your Acceptance of These Terms
Information We Collect
Information we collect directly from you: Your provision of your personal information to Us is completely voluntary; it is not a statutory or contractual requirement. Personally Identifiable Information (“PII”) is information that is uniquely identifiable to you, such as your name, address, email address, phone number, credit card number and other personal information that is not otherwise publicly available. Certain features of Our website may require that you provide Us with your personal information, including:
Mobile Alert Sign-Up (SMS)
Contact Us (email)
Public forums (e.g. message boards)
E-commerce (ticket purchases)
Your use of any of the features above;
New content on Our website;
News that We think may interest you about Us;
Responses to your questions/comments to us; and
Information relating to a ticket purchase.
We may use your demographic information for in house statistics, advertising and marketing target information. Our processing of your personal information is necessary for the performance and fulfillment of the contract between us and to provide you with Our services. We will also process, transfer, disclose and preserve personal information when We have a good faith belief that doing so is necessary, to resolve disputes, enforce our agreements and otherwise required by law. You can always opt-out of receiving future promotional communications from Us; see the Choice/Opt-out section below.Information We Collect Automatically: Even if you don’t use any of the features above, when you visit Our website, We may collect certain information about you.
From your Browser. For example, Our servers keep an activity log that tracks all visitors to the website. The information in the activity log does not identify you individually. The information collected may include among other data: your IP address, your registered domain or home server, time of access, date of access, web page(s) visited, number of clicks, software crash reports, type of browser used, session identification number, search terms, search results, access times and referring website’s address. We use your IP address to help diagnose problems with Our server and to administer Our website. Your IP address is also used to gather broad demographic information, such as country of origin and geographic location. We use such data in the aggregate to run internal analyses to improve upon your experience on Our website.
Tracking Tags (also known as “web beacons,” “action tags” or “single-pixel gifs”). Our website may also use tracking tags. Tracking tags are invisible graphics embedded in the pages of Our website that are programmed to collect non-personal information about your use of Our website. Like cookies, tracking tags provide overall usage patterns for Our website that We use for analysis and to provide personalized services and advertising content.
We comply with the Self-Regulatory Principles for Online Behavioral Advertising set forth by the Digital Advertising Alliance (DAA). You can opt-out of targeted advertising from certain providers at www.aboutads.info/consumers.
How We Use Your Personal Information
The personal information We collect allows Us to keep you posted on updates to Broadway Direct. It also helps Us to improve Our services, content, and advertising. If you don’t want to be on Our email list, you can opt out anytime by clicking the “unsubscribe” button or sending an unsubscribe email to [email protected]. From time to time, We may use your personal information to send transactional emails, such as communications about purchases and changes to Our terms, conditions, and policies. Because this information is important to your interaction with Broadway Direct, you may not opt out of receiving these communications. We may also use personal information for internal purposes such as auditing, data analysis, and research to improve Broadway Direct’s services, and customer communications. If you enter into a sweepstakes, contest, or similar promotion We may use the information you provide to administer those programs.
Information Collected By/Shared With Third Parties
Third Parties Doing Work for Us. Third parties have no rights to use any data We have collected on your behalf. However, We may employ other companies or individuals to perform functions on Our behalf, such as sending postal mail, email, and text messages, conducting sweepstakes/contests, prize fulfillment and promotional activities, analyzing data, providing marketing assistance, processing credit card payments and providing customer service. These outside suppliers, agents and vendors have access to your personal information only as needed to perform their functions.
Third Parties with Links from Our Website. From our website, you may be able to click on links to third party sites to buy tickets and merchandise and for other purposes. These third party sites may collect information, including personal information. We are not responsible for, nor do we have access to the information they collect. The collection of this information is governed by the privacy policies on the applicable third party sites.
Social Networking Services. Our website may integrate with social networking services. We do not control such services and are not liable for the manner in which they operate. While we may provide you with the ability to use such services in connection with our website, we are doing so merely as an accommodation and, like you, are relying upon those third party services to operate properly and fairly.
When necessary. We may also release personal information when we believe, in good faith, that such release is reasonably necessary to protect the rights, property or safety of Ourselves, Our clients, Our users, or others. We may disclose personal information about you to law enforcement, other government officials, or other third parties, as We, in our sole discretion, believe necessary or appropriate, in connection with an investigation of fraud, intellectual property infringement, or other activity that is illegal or may expose Us to legal liability.
Transactions With Third Party E-commerce Partners, Vendors and Advertisers
Delivery of Advertising and Other Content
In addition to ads and content that We may serve you directly, We use third-party advertising companies and marketing services companies to serve ads and other content when you visit Broadway Direct and elsewhere on the internet and in other media. Both We and these companies may use information about your visits to Broadway Direct and elsewhere to serve ads and other content to you. In the course of doing so, a unique third-party cookie may be placed or recognized on your browser by such companies. In addition, We and these companies may use Web beacons to help manage Our online advertising and content. These Web beacons enable Us and the third-party companies to recognize a browser’s cookie when a browser visits this Site and to learn which banner ads bring users to our website and to serve you ads that you may find of interest elsewhere on the internet and in other media. Both Broadway Direct and these companies may use information obtained from your visits to Broadway Direct or other websites, and information received from you offline in order to provide advertisements about goods and services and other content of interest to you across the internet and in other media. If you would like more information about this practice and to know your choices about not having this information used in this manner by Our third party advertising companies, please visit http://www.networkadvertising.org/optout_nonppii.asp and/or www.aboutads.info/choices. European users may opt out of receiving targeted advertising by visiting http://www.youronlinechoices.eu/. In addition, we may provide PII and Anonymous Information to marketing services companies. This may include information we received from you offline or online. These companies may combine information we provide (including PII and Anonymous Information) with personal and anonymous information they may have about you, using cookies they place or that We place on their behalf, as described in the section regarding “Cookies and Tracking Tags”. We require these companies to delete the PII we provide them. These companies may use the resulting non-personal information and such cookies for their own marketing purposes, and they may provide the same to their customers for their customer’s marketing purposes. Some of Our emails may contain tags that allow Us and Our advertisers and other partners to determine the types of content that may be of interest to you. Those tags may contain PII and may be shared with others to the same extent indicated in the section regarding “Cookies and Tracking Tags”. Those tags may not be deleted but you can opt out of receiving the emails.
Use of This Site by Children
The Site is not directed to individuals under the age of thirteen (13), and We request that such individuals do not provide personal information through the Site. If a parent or guardian becomes aware that his or her child has provided Us with PII without the parent or guardian’s consent by, for example, misrepresenting his or her age, that parent or guardian should contact us at [email protected]. If Broadway Direct determines that it has collected personal information of children under the age of 13, Broadway Direct will immediately delete such information and any accounts believed to be held by children under 13. In addition, we may not collect or process information from a citizen of an EU member state under the age of sixteen (16) without such person’s parental consent. If you are a citizen of an EU member state under the age of 16, please tell your parents that you are using the Site and have your parents email Us at [email protected] so that We may delete any information We may have collected about you.
California Civil Code § 1798.83 permits California residents to request information about whether we have disclosed personal information to any third parties for the third parties’ direct marketing purposes. California residents have the right to request in writing: (a) a list of the categories of Personal Information, such as name, email address and mailing address and the type of services provided to the customer that a business has disclosed to third parties (including affiliates that are separate legal entities) during the immediately preceding calendar year for the third parties’ direct marketing purposes and (b) the names and addresses of all such third parties. To make a request, please contact Us at the following email address: [email protected].
Rights of EU Data Subjects
If you are a resident of the European Union, under the GDPR, European Union residents, as data subjects, have the following rights:
Right to access – This right allows individuals to obtain confirmation as to whether or not personal information concerning him or her is being processed and provide access to such personal information. It also allows individuals to request details of the processing of his or her personal information, including, without limitation, categories of recipients to whom the personal information have been or will be disclosed and purposes of processing.
Right to rectify – This right allows individuals to rectify any inaccurate personal information about him or her.
Right to restrict processing – This right allows individuals to block or suppress processing of personal data under certain circumstances.
Right to be forgotten – This right is also known as the “right to erasure”. It is an individual’s right to have personal data erased or to prevent processing in specific circumstances.
Right of data portability – This right allows individuals to move, copy or transfer personal data from one place to another in a secure manner without interrupting the integrity and usability of the information.
Right to object to processing – This right allows individuals to object to certain types of processing, including direct marketing, profiling and providing for purposes of scientific or historical research and statistics.
An EU resident has the right to access his or her personal data that We hold and to ask that their personal data be corrected or erased and to port their data. An EU resident may also have the right to object to, or request that We restrict certain processing or to withdraw consent previously provided. If you would like to exercise your rights under the GDPR, please contact us at [email protected]. If you are an EU resident and have a concern about our processing of your personal data that we are not able to resolve, you have the right to lodge a complaint with the Data Protection Authority where you reside. For contact details of your relevant local Data Protection Authority, please see http://ec.europa.eu/newsroom/article29/item-detail.cfm?item_id=612080
Security of Your Personal Information
Broadway Direct employs reasonable security measures consistent with standard industry practice, for personal information collected through this Site, including physical, electronic and operational measures to maintain security and prevent unauthorized access. While Broadway Direct takes all appropriate steps to safeguard personal information under Our control, unfortunately, no data transmission over the Internet or method of storing data can be guaranteed to be 100% secure. As such, We cannot guarantee that personal information supplied by users will not be accessed on Our servers, or intercepted while being transmitted to Us over the Internet. We assume no liability for any damages you may suffer as a result of interception, alteration or misuse of information during such transfers.
We will retain your information for as long as your account or inquiry is active and for a reasonable time thereafter in accordance with Our standard procedures or as necessary to comply with Our legal obligations, to resolve disputes, and to enforce Our agreements. Even if We delete some or all of your Personal Information, We may continue to retain and use aggregate or anonymous data previously collected and/or anonymize or aggregate your Personal Information. Please note that We will not be liable for disclosures of your data due to errors or unauthorized acts of third parties.
This Site provides users the opportunity to opt-out of receiving communications from Us, at any time, by email at [email protected], or by clicking the unsubscribe link in any email communication. The Site gives users the following options for removing their information from our database, to not receive future communications or to no longer receive our service, at any time.
Users can send mail to the following postal address: Broadway Direct 1501 Broadway 14th floor New York, NY 10036
Users can call the following telephone number: (800) 223-6715.
Users can opt-out of receiving future newsletter emails from Us by selecting the “unsubscribe” link at the bottom of our email. However, We are not responsible for removing your information from the lists of any third party who has previously been provided with your information or is collecting your information through their cookies. You have the right to withdraw your consent for Our processing for your personal information by contacting us at [email protected].
This website gives users the following options for changing and modifying information previously provided, at any time.
Users can send mail to the following postal address: Broadway Direct 1501 Broadway 14th floor New York, NY 10036
Users can call the following telephone number: (800) 223-6715
In the event that We are, or any component of our operations is, merged with, or is acquired by, another entity, then any such successor or acquiring entity may become the successor to Our obligations with respect to the personal information that you have provided to Us, which would be necessary for the entity to effectively continue our business. By using this website, you consent to any transfer and use of such personal information by an entity assuming control of Our operations as a result of a merger, purchase of assets, or liquidation in bankruptcy or insolvency.