“So much has built up to this moment,” Broadway star Derek Klena tells Broadway Direct from the airport. He has just landed in Washington, D.C., and settles into a video chat amid the travelers around him.
He has an incredible week ahead — the pinnacle of an entire year as one of the newest baseball players on the Savannah Bananas. The big “Super Bowl,” or Banana Ball, streaming live on Disney+, is just a few days away. It’s the inaugural championship game of the Banana Ball Championship League, created by the Savannah Bananas. The Savannah, Georgia-based baseball team is known for its fast-paced, high-entertainment variation on traditional baseball and its sold-out crowds.

“I’ve been out of baseball for about 15 years, so coming in from Broadway and trying to compete with these guys, I was lucky to be welcomed with open arms,” he says of his experience.
Starring on Broadway and being a professional athlete don’t typically mix unless the two worlds intersect in a play or musical, like Damn Yankees, heading to Broadway this spring. For Klena, the cards had always been in the works. He just didn’t know it.
Growing up in California, Klena did both: played baseball and performed in shows. He was a high school pitcher and was recruited to play ball for the UCLA Bruins at the University of California, Los Angeles. But after his freshman year, he quit to focus solely on musical theatre.

It paid off. Klena made his Broadway debut as Fiyero in Wicked in 2013, followed by principal roles in The Bridges of Madison County, Anastasia and Moulin Rouge! The Musical. He earned a Tony Award nomination as Nick Healy in Jagged Little Pill.
During the summer months, many Broadway shows participate in a softball league on Thursday mornings in Central Park, around 60th Street on the West Side. “I thought it was the coolest thing ever. It was a way for me to carry my competitive side and still fulfill that on the field while participating in the show,” he says of playing in the league for the last 13 years.
Klena had just wrapped a second stint as Fiyero when EGOT-winning composers Justin Paul and Benj Pasek texted him out of the blue. They had previously worked together on the short-lived Off-Broadway musical Dogfight and several other projects. Pasek and Paul were writing original songs for the Savannah Bananas, and the team was considering adding another player to its roster to front the performances.

Pasek and Paul knew Klena would fit the lineup. But first, Klena had to send in the most unique audition tape of his career.
Along with seven minutes of footage showing him throwing 20 or 25 pitches, he dug into the archives to find a clip of himself at 13 on America’s Most Talented Kids, hosted by Dave Coulier.
“My introduction was, ‘This is Derek Klena. His dream is to play professional baseball and sing the national anthem before the game.’ I kept that clip in there, then put in a little bit of me singing at 13. Then I did a ‘this is now,’ and it was me at the final number singing ‘Come What May’ in Moulin Rouge!”
An in-person audition followed, and Klena landed the role of a full-time player, putting him on a national platform.
One of the season’s most viral performances featured Klena in an epic mashup with Kristen Bell, the voice of Anna in Frozen. A video featuring their live vocals and impressive choreography, culminating in the iconic Dirty Dancing lift, has garnered more than 46 million views on Instagram alone. Bell had reached out to the Bananas after seeing Ben Platt perform with the team.

“It was one of the coolest experiences,” Klena recalls of that August evening. “Getting to perform with her on the baseball field, in a place that’s overwhelming in so many different ways, and seeing her handle it like a pro felt like being out there with one of my Broadway friends.”
Klena was brought into the mix about three weeks beforehand “to help solidify the number.” On game day, they started rehearsing around 11 a.m., running through the number and choreography and working on camera blocking for about 45 minutes to an hour. A few hours later, the pair rehearsed the famous lift again — this time in the weight room — to make sure they had it down.
“Then we went for it,” Klena says of showtime. “It was craziness.”

With the triumphant baseball season on hiatus for the winter, Klena is focused on his upcoming theatrical engagements, including a celebrated return to Broadway. Klena will star as Jay Gatsby in The Great Gatsby at the Broadway Theatre beginning December 5.
“I am so excited to be returning to the Broadway stage after a year of performing on very different ones,” Klena shares exclusively with Broadway Direct. “I’m so grateful to be stepping into these patent leather shoes and can’t wait to put my body and voice to the test in the place I’m lucky enough to call home.”
Klena is also performing with the New York Pops at Carnegie Hall alongside Lindsay Mendez on December 18.
Once Klena’s limited run concludes on March 14, 2027, he will change back into his yellow uniform for another season with the Savannah Bananas.
“Theater is definitely where my heart and soul are,” he says. “The [Savannah Bananas] have just been the icing on the cake, allowing me to do both.”